As an analyst, every idea you have needs a yardstick. If you pick a stock and it rises 12% in a year, is that good? You can only answer by comparing it with what you'd have got from doing nothing clever: buying the whole market. That comparison is called a benchmark.
For US stocks, the default benchmark is the S&P 500. And the cheapest way to "buy the benchmark" is an ETF. If your analysis can't beat that, the honest move is to own the ETF.