The five-step rule
US companies follow a standard called ASC 606. Companies using IFRS follow IFRS 15, which uses the same five steps. To recognise revenue means to record it in the income statement. The steps:
- Find the contract. Is there a real agreement with a customer, with terms both sides accept and a customer likely to pay?
- List the promises. What separate things did the company promise to deliver? Each one is a performance obligation. A phone and a year of cloud storage are two promises.
- Set the price. What will the customer pay in total, after discounts, refunds and rebates the company expects?
- Split the price across the promises. Each promise gets a share based on what it would sell for on its own (its stand-alone selling price).
- Recognise each share when that promise is kept. Some promises are kept at one moment (handing over a phone). Others are kept over time (a month of streaming, every month).
Deferred revenue
Sometimes the customer pays before the company has kept its promise. A yearly subscription paid up front is the classic case.
The company has the cash, but hasn't earned it. So the money goes on the balance sheet as a liability called deferred revenue (or contract liability). It's a debt of service: the company owes the customer the rest of the year. Each month it delivers, it moves one month's worth from deferred revenue into revenue.
Customer pays $120 on 1 Jan for a year of service.
1 Jan: cash +$120, deferred revenue +$120, revenue $0
each month: deferred revenue −$10, revenue +$10
31 Dec: deferred revenue $0, revenue $120 for the year
Why subscriptions and bundles get tricky
- Subscriptions: cash arrives in a lump, revenue arrives in slices. Cash flow can look much better than profit early in a fast-growing subscription business.
- Bundles: when one price buys several promises, the company must estimate each promise's stand-alone price (step 4). Estimates involve judgement, and judgement can be stretched. If more of the price goes to the part delivered today, more revenue lands today.