Lesson 4 of 8

When is revenue really revenue?

Step 2 of 6

The idea

The five-step rule

US companies follow a standard called ASC 606. Companies using IFRS follow IFRS 15, which uses the same five steps. To recognise revenue means to record it in the income statement. The steps:

  1. Find the contract. Is there a real agreement with a customer, with terms both sides accept and a customer likely to pay?
  2. List the promises. What separate things did the company promise to deliver? Each one is a performance obligation. A phone and a year of cloud storage are two promises.
  3. Set the price. What will the customer pay in total, after discounts, refunds and rebates the company expects?
  4. Split the price across the promises. Each promise gets a share based on what it would sell for on its own (its stand-alone selling price).
  5. Recognise each share when that promise is kept. Some promises are kept at one moment (handing over a phone). Others are kept over time (a month of streaming, every month).

Deferred revenue

Sometimes the customer pays before the company has kept its promise. A yearly subscription paid up front is the classic case.

The company has the cash, but hasn't earned it. So the money goes on the balance sheet as a liability called deferred revenue (or contract liability). It's a debt of service: the company owes the customer the rest of the year. Each month it delivers, it moves one month's worth from deferred revenue into revenue.

Customer pays $120 on 1 Jan for a year of service.
1 Jan:   cash +$120, deferred revenue +$120, revenue $0
each month: deferred revenue −$10, revenue +$10
31 Dec:  deferred revenue $0, revenue $120 for the year

Why subscriptions and bundles get tricky

  • Subscriptions: cash arrives in a lump, revenue arrives in slices. Cash flow can look much better than profit early in a fast-growing subscription business.
  • Bundles: when one price buys several promises, the company must estimate each promise's stand-alone price (step 4). Estimates involve judgement, and judgement can be stretched. If more of the price goes to the part delivered today, more revenue lands today.