Lesson 7 of 8

Stock-based compensation is a real cost

Step 2 of 6

The idea

What it is

Stock-based compensation (SBC) is pay given as shares or rights to shares. The two common forms:

  • Restricted stock units (RSUs): a promise of shares that the employee receives over time, typically over several years, if they stay. Receiving them is called vesting.
  • Stock options: the right to buy shares later at a fixed price. Lesson 10 of Module 1 covered how options work.

Companies like SBC because it saves cash and keeps staff from leaving before their shares vest.

How it's counted

Under US GAAP, SBC is an expense. The company estimates the value of the award when it's granted and spreads that cost over the vesting years, like depreciation spreads the cost of a machine (lesson 05). So the net income in a 10-K is already after SBC.

But two places add it back:

  1. The cash flow statement. SBC reduced profit but no cash left, so it's added back to get operating cash flow. That makes operating cash flow look bigger than if staff had been paid in cash.
  2. "Adjusted" profit figures that many companies publish. They often leave SBC out. That's next lesson.

Why it's a real cost

Think of it this way. If the company paid staff $1B in cash and the staff used it to buy $1B of newly issued shares, nobody would call the $1B free. Paying in shares is the same deal with a step skipped.

Who pays? You, the shareholder, in one of two ways:

  • Dilution (Module 1, lesson 02): new shares go to staff, so your slice of the company shrinks.
  • Buybacks (Module 1, lesson 08): the company spends real cash buying shares back to stop the share count growing. Then the cash cost shows up, just in the financing section of the cash flow statement (money paid to or raised from owners and lenders) instead of the expense lines.

Aswath Damodaran, a valuation professor at NYU, answers "Is it an expense?" with "Of course!"