Airlines: most forces against them
| Force | Airlines |
|---|---|
| Rivalry | Strong: Delta calls the industry "highly competitive" on fares, routes and schedules; planes and staff cost money even when seats are empty |
| New entrants | Moderate: airport slots limit them, but new low-cost carriers do appear |
| Substitutes | Moderate: trains, cars, video calls on short or business trips |
| Buyers | Strong: travellers compare prices and switch for a few dollars |
| Suppliers | Strong: "a limited number of aircraft and engine manufacturers"; about 20% of Delta's staff, mainly pilots, are unionised; fuel is priced on world markets |
Quotes are from Delta's 2025 10-K (Items 1 and 1A). Now the numbers. From Damodaran's tables (data as of January 2026, 23 US air transport firms):
| Measure | Air Transport | Whole market |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-tax operating margin | 5.32% | 12.82% |
| Net margin | 2.51% | 9.74% |
| Return on capital | 7.93% | 15.07% (a) |
| Cost of capital | 6.72% | 7.72% (a) |
(a) US companies excluding financials, the course's "whole market" for returns (Module 6 lesson 03). The margin rows are Damodaran's Total Market row.
Airlines keep less than half the market's operating margin, and their return on capital is about half the market's (7.93% against 15.07%). It is still just above their own cost of capital (6.72%): the industry earns its keep, barely. Weak returns, but not value destruction.
Even the best carrier is far from rich. Delta Air Lines, calendar 2025 (10-K filed 11 Feb 2026):
Operating income $5,822M
Revenue $63,364M
Operating margin 5,822 ÷ 63,364 ≈ 9.2%
Visa and Mastercard: most forces in their favour
Visa and Mastercard run card networks, the rails that move a payment between your bank and the shop's bank. Banks issue the cards and do the lending.
| Force | Card networks |
|---|---|
| Rivalry | Limited: a few networks, led by Visa and Mastercard |
| New entrants | Weak: a new network needs both shoppers and shops at once |
| Substitutes | Growing: digital wallets, real-time bank payments and stablecoins (digital tokens pegged to a currency such as the dollar; Module 12), all listed in Visa's 10-K |
| Buyers | Mixed: shops dislike the fees but can't easily refuse cards |
| Suppliers | Weak: mainly computers and staff |
The numbers, from each company's own 10-K:
Visa, FY2026 (year ended 30 Sep 2026, filed 5 Nov 2026)
28,110 ÷ 45,903 ≈ 61.2% operating margin
Mastercard, calendar 2025 (filed 11 Feb 2026)
18,897 ÷ 32,791 ≈ 57.6% operating margin
More than six times Delta's margin.
The live exception: regulators. Margins this high draw attention. Visa's FY2026 10-K reports:
- the US Department of Justice sued Visa on 24 Sep 2024, alleging it monopolised US debit network services;
- on 23 Jun 2025 the court denied Visa's motion to dismiss, so the case goes on (no ruling on the claims yet);
- Congress has reintroduced the Credit Card Competition Act, which would require large banks to offer a choice of network for credit cards.
So "most forces favourable" holds, with a dated threat to track.