Lesson 7 of 7

Scuttlebutt: research beyond the filings

Step 2 of 7

The idea

Scuttlebutt is the investor Philip Fisher's word for gathering information about a company from the people around it: customers, suppliers, trade associations and former employees. This lesson sticks to public sources and customers' own experience: people who work for or with the company may owe it a duty of confidentiality, so don't ask them about anything unreleased.

Source What it can hint at Its limits
Use the product, visit the store Quality, crowds, staff, prices One location, one day
Customer reviews Complaints that keep repeating Angry people review more
App store rankings Downloads compared with rivals Downloads aren't usage or sales
Job postings Where the company is hiring or cutting Adverts aren't hires
Talking to customers and users Why they buy, whether they'd switch Small, biased sample

Each signal is weak alone. Their value is in agreeing with each other and pointing at a specific number you'll later check in a filing.

The legal line. Investor.gov, run by the SEC (the US markets regulator), defines it:

"Illegal insider trading refers generally to buying or selling a security, in breach of a fiduciary duty or other relationship of trust and confidence, on the basis of material, nonpublic information about the security. Insider trading violations may also include 'tipping' such information, securities trading by the person 'tipped,' and securities trading by those who misappropriate such information."

Two words carry the weight. In its Regulation FD rule (2000), the SEC uses the courts' definitions:

  • Material: there is "a substantial likelihood that a reasonable shareholder would consider it important" in making an investment decision.
  • Nonpublic: it "has not been disseminated in a manner making it available to investors generally".

Together that's material non-public information, MNPI for short. In practice:

  • Fine: anything public, that any investor could see or look up: a store's car park, a public app chart, a public review, a job advert, a customer's opinion of the product they bought.
  • Not fine: confidential company information from someone who owes the company a duty to keep it secret, such as an employee, a director, or a lawyer or banker working for it. Trading on it is what the definition above describes. So is passing it on (tipping), and trading on it when it's passed to you.

The same rule also explains why piecing together public clues is allowed. The SEC wrote that analysts "can provide a valuable service in sifting through and extracting information that would not be significant to the ordinary investor to reach material conclusions. We do not intend, by Regulation FD, to discourage this sort of activity." The skill is joining public dots, not obtaining secret ones.