Two numbers, two questions
- Price is what you pay: the number on the screen, set by buyers and sellers today. You can see it.
- Value (or intrinsic value) is what you get: what the business is worth from the cash it will produce for its owners over its whole life. Nobody can see it; you estimate it, and careful people disagree.
Two ways to put a number on a company
Aswath Damodaran, an NYU valuation professor, separates two activities:
- Valuing. Start from the business: the cash it makes, how fast that grows, what it must reinvest, how risky it is. Module 10 turns these into a number.
- Pricing. Start from the market: what investors pay for similar companies per dollar of profit or sales. You borrow the market's yardstick.
That yardstick is a multiple: a price divided by some measure of the business.
multiple = price ÷ a measure of the business (profit, sales, cash flow…)
Apple's "years of profit" in Module 1 (market cap ÷ net income) was one.
What moves each one
Damodaran's 2024 slides list what drives each side:
| Value is driven by | Price is driven by |
|---|---|
| Cash flows from the assets the company has now | Mood and momentum: fear, greed, panic |
| Growth, and the reinvestment it needs | Incremental information: news and rumours, measured against what people expected |
| Risk in those cash flows | Liquidity: how easy the shares are to trade |
| How long the company can keep an edge | Group think: following the herd |
Both matter; don't mix them
- If you'll sell in a month, pricing is what pays you: what others will pay next month.
- If you'll hold for years, value is what you own: you're betting price moves towards value over time.
A multiple is a description, not a verdict. "It trades at 20 times profit; rivals trade at 30" describes how the market prices it. Maybe the rivals are overpriced; maybe this company is riskier. Only the value questions can tell.