Lesson 7 of 7

Exchange and custody risk

Step 3 of 6

Worked example

FTX, 2022, from the appeals-court opinion and the CFTC.

Meant to be: a huge exchange that, the CFTC alleged, represented customer assets as held in "custody", segregated from its own.

What failed: Alameda Research, a trading firm, was FTX's largest customer and main market maker; Sam Bankman-Fried controlled both (the court). The CFTC complaint alleged customer assets were "routinely accepted and held by Alameda and commingled with Alameda's funds", and that FTX's code gave Alameda an undisclosed "allow negative flag" and an "effectively limitless line of credit".

Date What happened
2 Nov 2022 A news site publishes Alameda's balance sheet; withdrawals surge
11 Nov 2022 Bankman-Fried replaced as CEO; FTX, unable to meet withdrawals, files for bankruptcy
13 Dec 2022 CFTC complaint alleges "the loss of over $8 billion in FTX customer deposits"
Nov 2023 – Mar 2024 Convicted on all seven counts of fraud and conspiracy; sentenced to 25 years and forfeiture of about $11B
12 Jun 2026 Second Circuit affirms the conviction
10 Sep 2026 Petition to the Supreme Court filed (No. 26-349); the government's response is due 16 Dec 2026

Repayments. Wikipedia's FTX bankruptcy page (out of date) quotes a 2023 estimate that customers would recover 118–142% "of their Petition Date claim values". Payouts of over $10B since Feb 2025 are press reports; check the FTX Recovery Trust's own site in your browser. Claims were fixed in dollars at November 2022 prices, so ">100%" did not hand back the coins themselves.

What an outsider could see. Known: the exchange's founder also controlled its biggest trader, a related-party set-up (Module 6, lesson 09). Hidden: the code features, which the CFTC alleged "were not disclosed to the public".

Binance, 2026: theft, not misuse. The US Department of Justice's release of 12 Nov 2026 (Module 12, lesson 05) says North Korean military hackers stole more than $6 billion of crypto from Binance on or about 29 Oct, and more than $2.7 billion had been frozen. How the attackers got in, and how losses were covered, is known only from press reports (20 Nov 2026). Binance publishes proof of reserves on its site; a snapshot can't say whether coins will be stolen the next day.

Checklist: before trusting a custodian, ask

  1. Who holds the keys, and what is my claim if the company fails?
  2. Are customer assets segregated, per a filing, not just its website?
  3. Does it lend, stake or pledge customer coins?
  4. Is its proof of reserves recent, and what doesn't it cover?
  5. Who regulates it?
  6. How much would I lose if this one company failed tomorrow?

One checklist for anything in crypto

Before trusting any coin, protocol or company:

  1. Who can move or freeze it? You, an exchange, the issuer, a council that can upgrade it (Module 12).
  2. What backs it, and can it be redeemed? (lesson 06)
  3. Who pays the yield? Users' fees, or new tokens? (lesson 04)
  4. Who can change the rules, and how fast? Votes, admin keys, upgrades (lesson 05)
  5. What would you lose if it failed tomorrow, and has it failed before?
  6. Is anything asking you to connect, sign, borrow or share your seed phrase? Stop.