Lesson 1 of 8

What changes when there's no stock price

Step 2 of 6

The idea

Four things that change

  1. No market price. The only "price" is what the owner asks; you have to work out value yourself.
  2. Less information. No 10-K, no SEC filings, often no audit. You get what the owner chooses to show you.
  3. Illiquidity. A small business can take many months to sell, not seconds (Module 1).
  4. Owner-dependent results. The owner is often manager, salesperson and repair crew; the profit may leave with them.

Why a private buyer uses a higher discount rate

In Module 10 you met the cost of equity: risk-free rate + beta × equity risk premium. Beta measures how much a stock moves with the whole market. It only counts market risk, because a diversified investor owning hundreds of stocks has spread away the rest (how spreading works is Module 16).

A person who puts most of their savings into one car wash hasn't spread anything away. They carry all of the business's risk. Damodaran (ch. 24) handles this with a total beta. In words: the market beta divided by how closely the business moves with the market, its correlation.

Correlation is a number from −1 to +1. At +1 the business always moves in step with the market; at 0 there is no link. (Module 16 lesson 02 teaches it.) A car wash's results barely follow the stock market, so its correlation is low and most of its risk is its own.

total beta = market beta ÷ correlation with the market

Dividing by a number below 1 makes it bigger: the lower the correlation, the bigger the total beta. A higher beta means a higher discount rate, which means a lower value.

The illiquidity discount

Buyers also knock something off for not being able to sell quickly. Studies of "restricted stock" (listed shares that can't be sold for a period), summarised in Damodaran's chapter, found discounts of about a third; one (Silber, 1984–89 data) found a median of 33.75%. Decades-old samples, not a rule, but they show the size of the effect.

Who can invest in private deals

  • A private placement is a sale of shares (or other securities) that isn't registered with the SEC. Under Rule 506(b), the SEC's page says a company can raise any amount from any number of accredited investors, but it can't advertise the offering, and it can sell to at most 35 non-accredited investors in any 90-day period.
  • An accredited investor is someone the rules treat as able to look after themselves. The SEC's page (reviewed 24 April 2026) lists, for individuals: net worth over $1 million excluding the main home (alone or with a spouse or partner), or income over $200,000 alone ($300,000 joint) in each of the last two years with the same expected this year, or holding a Series 7, 65 or 82 licence in good standing.

A change is under discussion, not law: on 5 October 2026 the SEC published two notices saying it is considering adding CPA licence holders and CFA charterholders to that list, with comments due by 4 December 2026.

These are US rules, stated as the regulator's pages put them. Anyone actually buying into a private business or deal works with a lawyer and an accountant.