Lesson 4 of 8

Due diligence and quality of earnings

Step 3 of 6

Worked example

The invented car wash again: reported revenue $800,000, SDE $240,000, asking price $600,000 (2.5× SDE). Applying the checklist turns up three red flags. All invented, all common.

Red flag 1: the cash doesn't reach the bank. Twelve months of bank statements show sales deposits of $742,000, not $800,000. The owner says some customers pay in cash and he "doesn't always bank it".

gap = reported revenue − banked sales
    = $800,000 − $742,000 = $58,000 (7.25% of revenue)

You can't verify that $58,000. If it isn't real, it was pure profit on the books, so SDE drops by the full amount. (Also check the other way: strip loans and owner transfers out of the deposits before comparing.)

Red flag 2: the "one-off" repair isn't. Repair records show a major pump or brush repair in each of the last three years. The $15,000 add-back from lesson 02 should go.

Red flag 3: the lease. The site lease ends in two years with no renewal option. A car wash can't move its equipment to a new site cheaply. Without a longer lease, the earnings may last two years, not indefinitely.

What the first two do to the price at the same 2.5× multiple:

Step SDE Price at 2.5×
As listed $240,000 $600,000
Remove unbanked revenue $182,000 $455,000
Remove the recurring repair $167,000 $417,500

The lease isn't in the table because it isn't a number to adjust. It's a question that has to be answered before any price makes sense.