Lesson 1 of 8

Risk is permanent loss, not just wiggles

Step 2 of 6

The idea

In Module 2 you met volatility (how much a price wiggles) and drawdown (the fall from a peak to a trough), plus the loss-recovery table: −50% needs +100%, −75% needs +300%, −90% needs +900%. You also saw Howard Marks' view that risk is mainly the chance of permanent loss.

This lesson splits every big fall into two kinds:

  • A temporary fall. The price drops, but the thing you own is still there and still worth something. If you don't have to sell, you can wait.
  • A permanent loss. The thing you own is broken, gone or never was what you thought. Waiting doesn't help. Marks, in Risk Revisited: "we never get a chance to undo a permanent loss."

The hard part: while they happen, both look the same on a chart. A −66% fall and a −99% fall share the same first −30%.

Four risks a price chart can't show you

  1. Leverage. Borrowed money (Module 1 lesson 09). A fall you could have waited out becomes permanent if the lender sells you out at the bottom (lesson 06).
  2. Fraud. The numbers, the reserves or the people were not what they claimed. No amount of waiting fixes it.
  3. Obsolescence. The business still exists but its product stops mattering. The price slides and never returns.
  4. Custody. Custody means who actually holds your asset. If a broker or exchange holds it for you and that firm fails, you may not get it back, even if the asset itself is fine.

A useful question for any holding: "If this halves, will it still exist, and can I keep holding it?" If both answers are yes, a big fall is mostly volatility. If either is no, it is risk.