Lesson 1 of 9

Confirmation bias and overconfidence

Step 4 of 6

Do it yourself

Small and practical. Do it now while it is fresh.

About 10 minutes. Pick the company from the course you like most (Apple, Costco or Nvidia, say).

  1. Before re-reading anything positive, write the three strongest arguments against it. Use numbers from the course where you can.
  2. Turn your single value for it into a range: a low and a high, with one sentence on what would put it at each end.
  3. Rate how sure you are, from 50% to 100%, that the true value lies in your range.
Show a model answer (Costco, Module 10)
  1. Three arguments against: (a) my DCF gave $426.47 a share against a price of $1,093.83 on 19 Nov 2026; in that model the price needs an operating margin of about 8.9% every year, more than twice today's. (b) Growth fades as companies get bigger, and Costco is already very large (FY2026 revenue $303.2B). (c) The thesis rests on members renewing; if the 92.3% renewal rate slipped, the fee income that funds low prices would weaken.
  2. Range (illustrative): $320–$700 a share. Low end: Damodaran's industry sales-to-capital (Module 10 lesson 10: $325.91). High end: margins and growth well above my base case for many years.
  3. About 70%. If you wrote 95% for a range that narrow, ask yourself why.

Next lesson: Loss aversion, anchoring and herding, three more biases that bite hardest when a price moves against you or a crowd moves without you.