Lesson 3 of 9

Base rates and the outside view

Step 2 of 6

The idea

A base rate is how often an outcome happens across a group of similar cases. That group is called the reference class. "What share of large companies grew sales 20% a year for ten years?" is a base-rate question.

There are two ways to make a forecast:

  • The inside view: start from the details of this case (its products, managers, plans) and reason forward. It's how we naturally think, and it tends to be too hopeful.
  • The outside view: start from the base rate for the reference class, then adjust for what is genuinely different about this case.

Four steps for the outside view:

  1. Pick the reference class. Companies of similar size, or in the same industry, or both.
  2. Find the base rate. How often did cases like this reach the outcome you are forecasting?
  3. Adjust, a little. Move away from the base rate only for reasons you can write down.
  4. Flag the gap. If your forecast sits far outside what has happened before, say so in your notes. You may be right, but it's a rare claim.

Base rates are a check on lesson 01's overconfidence.