Lesson 4 of 9

Keep a decision journal

Step 2 of 6

The idea

Module 2 lesson 05 showed that a good bet can still lose. A journal lets you check which of four boxes each decision landed in:

Good outcome Bad outcome
Good reasoning Deserved success Bad luck: keep the process
Poor reasoning Dumb luck: don't repeat it Deserved: fix the process

Without a written record you can't tell the boxes apart, because you only remember the outcome. The most dangerous box is "dumb luck": it teaches you the wrong lesson and feels like skill.

The BEAST journal template

Copy this into your notes or a spreadsheet (one column per field). Fill in the top on the day you decide, the bottom on the review date.

DECISION JOURNAL ENTRY

Date:
The decision:              (what I'm doing, including size, or deciding not to do)
What I expect, by when:    (a checkable event and a date)
How sure I am:             (a probability, e.g. 70%)
My reasons:                (2–3 lines; the numbers they rest on)
What would make me wrong: (specific facts, not feelings)
How I feel right now:      (calm, excited, anxious, tired, rushed, under pressure...)
Review date:

--- fill in on the review date ---
Outcome:                   (what actually happened)
Was I right, and why?:     (reasoning, luck, or both? which box above?)
What I learned:

Three rules make it work:

  • Make expectations checkable. "Nvidia does well" can't be scored. "Data Center revenue is higher than a year earlier in the next quarterly report" can.
  • Put a number on your confidence. It turns a hunch into something you can score.
  • Write how you feel. Lessons 01 and 02 showed that fear, excitement and the urge to act are where biases enter. Farnam Street's template has a list of states to tick (energised, tired, anxious and others) for the same reason.

Scoring your confidence (optional)

A simple score is the Brier score: (your probability − the outcome)², where the outcome is 1 if the event happened and 0 if not. Lower is better. Saying "50%" every time scores 0.25, so over many entries you want to average below that.