Lesson 5 of 9

The pre-mortem

Step 2 of 6

The idea

A post-mortem finds the cause of a death. A pre-mortem does that for a decision before you make it.

Gary Klein developed it about 30 years ago for his company's project teams. In his description (Psychology Today, 2021), you pretend you are looking into a crystal ball, and "the plan you've just discussed has turned out to be a failure. A fiasco. That much is certain." Then each person takes two minutes to write down the reasons it failed. A team session can take as little as 20–30 minutes.

Done alone, for an investment:

  1. Set the scene. "It is one year from today. This position has lost most of its value." Treat that as certain.
  2. Two minutes, write every reason you can think of. Don't judge them yet.
  3. Rate each one for likelihood, impact and how easily you could prevent it.
  4. Two more minutes on actions: what you'll change now, such as size, custody, or a written kill rule (a fact that means you sell if it happens; lesson 08's kill criteria). (Klein added steps 3 and 4 in later years.)

Why it works, and how strong the evidence is

  • One laboratory study with students. Klein's summary of Veinott, Klein and Wiggins (2010): 178 college students critiqued a hypothetical plan for a university facing an H1N1 flu epidemic. The pre-mortem group showed "the greatest reduction in (over)confidence", compared with a simple critique or listing pros and cons. A made-up plan, summarised by one of the authors (the paper itself could not be checked): there it reduced overconfidence, no more.
  • Why certainty matters. You may read that it makes people "30% better" at finding reasons. That figure isn't supported: the study usually cited, Mitchell, Russo and Pennington (1989), found in its first experiment that placing the event in the past or future "showed little influence"; what changed people's explanations was whether the outcome was stated as certain. So say "it failed", not "it might fail".

Inversion

The pre-mortem is a form of inversion: asking how to get the opposite of what you want. In his 1986 Harvard School speech, Charlie Munger told "a story they told me when I was very young about a rustic who said: 'I wish I knew where I was going to die, and then I'd never go there.'" He added that the mathematician Jacobi "was known for his constant repetition of one phrase: 'Invert, always invert.'"