A post-mortem finds the cause of a death. A pre-mortem does that for a decision before you make it.
Gary Klein developed it about 30 years ago for his company's project teams. In his description (Psychology Today, 2021), you pretend you are looking into a crystal ball, and "the plan you've just discussed has turned out to be a failure. A fiasco. That much is certain." Then each person takes two minutes to write down the reasons it failed. A team session can take as little as 20–30 minutes.
Done alone, for an investment:
- Set the scene. "It is one year from today. This position has lost most of its value." Treat that as certain.
- Two minutes, write every reason you can think of. Don't judge them yet.
- Rate each one for likelihood, impact and how easily you could prevent it.
- Two more minutes on actions: what you'll change now, such as size, custody, or a written kill rule (a fact that means you sell if it happens; lesson 08's kill criteria). (Klein added steps 3 and 4 in later years.)
Why it works, and how strong the evidence is
- One laboratory study with students. Klein's summary of Veinott, Klein and Wiggins (2010): 178 college students critiqued a hypothetical plan for a university facing an H1N1 flu epidemic. The pre-mortem group showed "the greatest reduction in (over)confidence", compared with a simple critique or listing pros and cons. A made-up plan, summarised by one of the authors (the paper itself could not be checked): there it reduced overconfidence, no more.
- Why certainty matters. You may read that it makes people "30% better" at finding reasons. That figure isn't supported: the study usually cited, Mitchell, Russo and Pennington (1989), found in its first experiment that placing the event in the past or future "showed little influence"; what changed people's explanations was whether the outcome was stated as certain. So say "it failed", not "it might fail".
Inversion
The pre-mortem is a form of inversion: asking how to get the opposite of what you want. In his 1986 Harvard School speech, Charlie Munger told "a story they told me when I was very young about a rustic who said: 'I wish I knew where I was going to die, and then I'd never go there.'" He added that the mathematician Jacobi "was known for his constant repetition of one phrase: 'Invert, always invert.'"