Lesson 5 of 6

Private capstone: buy a franchise unit?

Step 3 of 6

Worked example

"Brightwater Express Wash", the invented franchise from Module 15 lesson 05: royalty 6% and marketing fund 2% of gross sales; Item 7 total investment $420,000–$780,000; Item 19 median gross sales $590,000 for the 48 of 60 outlets open all last year, no costs; 11.7% of outlets left last year (Item 20).

Steps 1–3. Fees at the median: 590,000 × 8% = $47,200 a year, paid whatever the profit. Costs are our invented estimates; chemicals, water and power take the car wash's 18.75% of sales (Module 15 lesson 02).

Line (invented estimate) $ a year
Gross sales (Item 19 median) 590,000
Royalty and marketing fund (8%) −47,200
Chemicals, water, power (18.75%) −110,625
Staff wages, rent, repairs and other −289,000
SDE (before owner's pay, loan, tax) 143,175

Item 7's midpoint is $600,000.

Step 4. 10% down, so a $540,000 loan at 10.00% over 10 years: $85,634 a year (Module 15 lesson 06).

DSCR on SDE:            143,175 ÷ 85,634            = 1.67
DSCR with a manager:    (143,175 − 50,000) ÷ 85,634 = 1.09
Sales fall 20%:         SDE 143,175 − 86,435 = 56,740 → DSCR 0.66

A sales fall of under 2% takes cover with a manager to 1.0; break-even sales are $579,705, just under the median.

Step 5. Run it yourself and you keep 143,175 − 85,634 = $57,541 a year: only $7,541 more than a $50,000 manager earns, for $60,000 of savings, the loan and perhaps a personal guarantee.

Step 6. Pre-mortem. It failed: year-one sales fell short (new outlets aren't in Item 19); costs ran above our estimates; a rival opened nearby.

Step 7. The memo (Module 17 lesson 09's template).

MEMO — Brightwater unit (invented), 20 Nov 2026, price $600,000 (Item 7 midpoint). Sources: Items 5–7, 19, 20; our cost estimates.

Heading Content
DECISION Do nothing: pass on this unit at these numbers. With a manager, the loan is covered 1.09 times; a 20% fall leaves 0.66 even if I run it; running it pays me about $7,500 more than a manager.
THESIS Tested and failed: a typical unit, run with a manager, pays its loan and survives a bad year.
FACTS Median sales $590,000 (48 of 60 outlets); fees 8%; 11.7% of outlets left last year.
VALUATION SDE $143,175 (my estimate); payback 6.4 years after a manager.
WHAT THE PRICE ASSUMES Median sales or better: break-even with a manager is $579,705.
VARIANT VIEW None: no evidence this unit would beat the median.
CATALYSTS The next FDD.
RISKS Year-one sales below the median; costs above my estimates; a rival nearby.
WHAT WOULD MAKE ME WRONG Figures I can check (an Item 19 with costs, a lender's term sheet) showing that, run by me, the unit covers its loan after a 20% fall: SDE of about $172,000 at the median (costs about $29,000 below my estimates), or a loan of at most about $358,000, which needs a total cost near $398,000, below Item 7's low end. Then reopen.
SIZE None.
OPEN QUESTIONS None that could change it, short of the line above.
REVIEW DATE When the next FDD is issued, or 20 Nov 2027: check Items 7 and 19 against the line above.

Journal entry (Module 17 lesson 04): The decision: do nothing; sign and pay nothing. What I expect, by when: the next FDD's median stays below about $639,000 (where, on my costs, an owner-run unit covers the loan after a 20% fall), by 20 Nov 2027; 75% sure. What would make me wrong: the memo's reopening line. How I feel right now: a little flat; relieved to have a rule. Review date: 20 Nov 2027.