Lesson 4 of 7

What a moat is (and isn't)

Step 3 of 6

Worked example

See's Candies, which Berkshire owns, is Buffett's "prototype of a dream business". All figures come from the 2007 letter ("Businesses – The Great, the Good and the Gruesome"). They are pre-tax, as Buffett gives them.

1972 (bought) 2007
Sales $30M $383M
Pre-tax profit under $5M $82M
Capital needed to run it $8M $40M
Candy sold 16M pounds 31M pounds

Return on the capital in the business, in words: pre-tax profit divided by the capital needed to run it.

1972:  under 5 ÷ 8, so under 62.5% (Buffett: "earning 60% pre-tax on invested capital")
2007:  82 ÷ 40 ≈ 205%

How much more money did it need? Only 40 − 8 = $32M over 35 years. Meanwhile pre-tax earnings totalled $1.35 billion, and all but that $32M was sent up to Berkshire to invest elsewhere.

Where did the growth come from? Not volume: pounds sold grew about 2% a year (the letter's figure). My own arithmetic, dividing sales by pounds:

1972:  $30M  ÷ 16M lb ≈ $1.88 per pound
2007:  $383M ÷ 31M lb ≈ $12.35 per pound
Growth: 12.35 ÷ 1.88 ≈ 6.6 times in 35 years, about 5.5% a year

Much of that is inflation: average US consumer prices rose about 5 times over the same years (CPI 41.8 in 1972, 207.3 in 2007). So See's raised prices a little faster than inflation, kept its customers, and needed almost no new capital to do it. That's a brand working as a moat: it shows in prices, returns and years, not in how famous the name is. The capital stayed small because candy "was sold for cash" (no customer debts to fund) and the production cycle was short (little inventory).

The 1983 letter puts it another way: See's earned "about $2 million on $8 million of net tangible assets" (after tax, so smaller than the pre-tax figure above), while a "mundane business" earning the same $2 million on $18 million earns only 11%.

My judgement, and what would change it. The evidence for a moat is returns that stayed very high for 35 years with little new capital. If returns had drifted towards ordinary levels, or price rises had cost it volume, I'd say the moat was narrowing. Bring that test to any company.