Lesson 4 of 7

What a moat is (and isn't)

Step 4 of 6

Do it yourself

Small and practical. Do it now while it is fresh.

About 10 minutes. The same 2007 letter describes FlightSafety, Berkshire's pilot-training business. Buffett says it "possesses a durable competitive advantage". His figures:

  • 1996 (bought): pre-tax operating earnings $111M.
  • 2007: pre-tax operating earnings $270M, a gain of $159M.

Find the last figure yourself: open the 2007 letter, search for FlightSafety, and find how much extra Berkshire had to invest over those years (the letter calls it "incremental investment").

  1. Work out FlightSafety's pre-tax return on the extra money: gain in earnings ÷ extra investment.
  2. Do the same for See's: gain in pre-tax earnings (from "under $5M" to $82M) ÷ the extra $32M.
  3. Both have a durable advantage, by Buffett's account. Why does he call See's "great" and FlightSafety only "good"?
Show answer
  1. The extra investment was $509M (fixed assets rose from $570M to $1,079M, with much of the spending on simulators). 159 ÷ 509 ≈ 31%.
  2. At least (82 − 5) ÷ 32 ≈ 240%, more because 1972 earnings were under $5M.
  3. A model answer: both are protected from rivals, but FlightSafety must keep spending heavily to grow (Buffett calls it "put-up-more-to-earn-more"), while See's grew its profits with almost no new capital. A moat protects returns; how much capital growth needs decides how great the business is.

Next lesson: The five sources of a moat, the specific advantages that create a moat, with a test for each.