You need two numbers.
Return on invested capital (ROIC), from Module 6: after-tax operating profit on the money tied up in the business.
ROIC = after-tax operating profit ÷ invested capital
Invested capital is the money lenders and shareholders have put into the business. Module 6's simplest version is debt plus equity; the table below also subtracts cash.
Cost of capital: the yearly return lenders and shareholders expect for the risk they take. It is Module 2's discount rate seen from the company's side. It blends:
- the cost of debt: the interest rate lenders charge, after the tax saving (interest is deducted before tax, so it cuts the tax bill);
- the cost of equity: the return shareholders expect, which is higher because they are paid last.
Weighted by how much of each the company uses, this blend is called WACC (weighted average cost of capital). For now, take it from a table.
The rule:
| ROIC compared with cost of capital | What growth does |
|---|---|
| ROIC above | Each new dollar invested creates value |
| ROIC equal | Growth adds nothing for owners |
| ROIC below | Each new dollar invested destroys value |
To put a dollar figure on it, use economic profit, also called economic value added (EVA): profit left after charging the business for all the capital it uses.
economic profit = (ROIC − cost of capital) × invested capital
A toy example
Two companies, both with a cost of capital of 8%, both with $100M invested. Each doubles to $200M.
| Company A | Company B | |
|---|---|---|
| ROIC | 15% | 5% |
| Economic profit at $100M | (15% − 8%) × 100 = +$7M | (5% − 8%) × 100 = −$3M |
| Economic profit at $200M | (15% − 8%) × 200 = +$14M | (5% − 8%) × 200 = −$6M |
Both doubled, and both report higher profit: B's rose from $5M to $10M. But B's owners now fall $6M a year short of what their money could earn elsewhere, twice as much as before. Growth made B's problem bigger.