Lesson 6 of 7

Value is created only when ROIC beats the cost of capital

Step 3 of 6

Worked example

Aswath Damodaran, a finance professor at NYU, publishes ROIC and cost of capital for every US industry each January. His table calls ROIC "ROC" and defines it as after-tax operating income ÷ (book debt + book equity − cash). Book means the amounts on the balance sheet, not market prices. Figures below are his US table, as of January 2026 data, re-read on 20 Nov 2026.

Auto & Truck (33 companies):

ROC − cost of capital = 2.25% − 9.38% = −7.13%
Invested capital (book)  = $539,547.76M
Economic profit = −7.13% × 539,547.76 ≈ −$38,470M

The table shows −$38,484.22M; the small gap is because the percentages are rounded. The industry earned about $38.5B a year less than its investors required.

Semiconductor (66 companies):

ROC − cost of capital = 27.23% − 10.55% = +16.68%
Invested capital (book)  = $647,009.44M
Economic profit = 16.68% × 647,009.44 ≈ +$107,921M

The table shows +$107,897.54M. About $108B a year above what investors required.

Across the whole table, 89 industries have a figure for ROC minus cost of capital, including the insurance and asset-management rows. (Banks, brokers, non-bank financials and building materials show no figure. ROIC is a poor fit for banks anyway, because borrowing and lending money is their business, so debt can't be treated as just a way of funding it.) 15 of the 89 earned below their cost of capital. For all US companies excluding financials, ROC was 15.07% against a cost of capital of 7.72%. Because of the banks problem, that is the row this course uses as "the whole market".

From industry to company

The rule is really about a company, so set your company's ROIC against the cost of capital of its industry row. Apple's ROIC was 72.0% in fiscal 2026 (Module 6 lesson 03). Damodaran puts Apple in Computers/Peripherals, cost of capital 9.71%:

72.0% − 9.71% = +62.3 points
Economic profit ≈ 62.3% × $182.3B average invested capital ≈ $114B a year

Two cautions. Module 6's ROIC doesn't subtract cash and Damodaran's does (subtracting Apple's cash would push its ROIC higher still). And the row's cost of capital is an industry average, not Apple's own; Module 10 estimates a company's own.

Which row is my company in? Damodaran's industry-name file (an Excel download of about 22 MB, January 2026 data) lists each company he covers with one Industry Group. Open the By company name sheet and search for your company. If its segments (Module 5) span several industries, check the rows for its biggest segments too. If their costs of capital are close, use the listed group; if not, weight them by each segment's share of revenue, and say that you did.

Two cautions:

  • These are averages. A strong company can sit inside a weak industry, and the other way round.
  • They are one year of data. The question for a moat is whether a company stays above its cost of capital for many years, not whether it did once.