Lesson 8 of 9

Writing a thesis: variant view and catalysts

Step 2 of 6

The idea

A thesis is your short written case for an investment. Module 16 lesson 07 used one line; a full thesis has four parts.

1. What the market believes. What the price assumes, not what people say on TV, from Module 10 lesson 09's reverse DCF, in one sentence.

2. Your variant view. A variant view is the specific point where you disagree with what the price assumes, and why. Howard Marks puts the problem bluntly in Dare to Be Great II (2014): "people who want to be above average can't expect to get there by engaging in conventional behavior… they have to bear the risk of being different and worse." He quotes his own 2006 memo: "Non-consensus ideas have to be lonely."

Test it against the outside view (lesson 03). If you can't find one, you agree with the price: no edge, and "do nothing" is the honest answer.

3. Catalysts. A catalyst is a dated or checkable event that will show whether you or the market is right: an earnings release, a filing, a customer's announcement. Without one, you could be right for years and never see it in the price.

4. What would make me wrong. Also called kill criteria: the facts that would show your variant view is wrong, written before you buy, when you're calm. Lesson 05's pre-mortem helps you find them. They become row 1 of your sell rules (Module 16 lesson 07).

The thesis frame. Copy this:

THESIS — <asset>, <date>, price <x>

1. The market believes:      <the reverse-DCF sentence, with whose model it is>
2. My variant view:          <two sentences: where I differ, and why>
   Outside view check:       <how often cases like this happen (17-03)>
3. Catalysts:                <up to 3 events, each with a date or a source to watch>
4. What would make me wrong: <up to 3 checkable facts, each with a number (17-05)>
Review date:                 <a date; log the thesis in your decision journal (17-04)>