Lesson 8 of 9

Writing a thesis: variant view and catalysts

Step 4 of 6

Do it yourself

Small and practical. Do it now while it is fresh.

About 10 minutes. Here's a weak thesis: "Costco is a great company with loyal members, so the stock will keep going up."

Rewrite it with the frame, using Module 10 lesson 10's result: Costco at $1,093.83 (19 Nov 2026) against a model value of about $426 a share. Fill in parts 1 and 2 honestly; part 2 can be "none yet".

Show a model answer
  1. The market believes: in my Module 10 model, the price needs an operating margin of about 8.9% every year (more than twice today's 3.85%), or a cost of capital of about 5.7% (a beta near 0.15). The template sits about 15% low on its own (Module 10 lesson 07); this gap is about 60%, so most of it isn't the tool. The price assumes much more than Costco's history: perhaps more fee income, or growth for far longer.
  2. My variant view: none yet. "Great company, loyal members" is what the market already believes: renewal rates of 92.3% in the US and Canada are public. I can't say where I differ. 3–4. Catalysts, what would make me wrong: not needed until I have a view.

Conclusion: this is not a thesis. The honest decision is "research more", with the question "what growth, for how long, does the price assume?" Lesson 09 turns this into a memo.

Next lesson: The one-page investment memo, putting thesis, valuation, risks and a decision on one page.