In his memo Selling Out (January 2022), Howard Marks says people mostly sell "because they're up and because they're down", and both are weak reasons. Good reasons, he writes, "should be based on the outlook for the investment – not the psyche of the investor".
From his memo, four reasons to review a position:
- The thesis breaks. Your thesis is the short written case for owning something. If it "seems less valid than it did previously", Marks says selling some or all is "probably appropriate". Write down the facts that would show it wrong.
- The price runs far past value. Well above your own estimate of value (Modules 9 and 10), the return you can expect from here has shrunk. A reason to compare, not to sell automatically.
- A better use of the money appears. Marks calls this opportunity cost: what you give up by choosing one use of money over another. A new idea with a "superior risk-adjusted prospective return" (more expected return for the risk) is a fair reason to switch.
- The position is too big. A winner that grows past your per-position cap (lesson 05) carries more risk than you chose.
Not on the list: "it's up a lot", "it's down a lot", "I want to lock in the gain". A price move is a reason to look at the list, nothing more.
Your review point goes on the card too. It is lesson 03's number: the fall you sized the position with. Reaching it means you re-read the thesis, not that you sell.
The counterpoint. Berkshire Hathaway's Owner's Manual (1996) says: "Regardless of price, we have no interest at all in selling any good businesses that Berkshire owns." Warren Buffett admits this "hurts our financial performance". Both decided their rule in advance and wrote it down.