Lesson 7 of 8

When to sell

Step 4 of 6

Do it yourself

Small and practical. Do it now while it is fresh.

About 10 minutes. Pick one holding you own, or one you've analysed in an earlier module.

  1. Write the thesis in one line.
  2. Write one rule for each of the four reasons, plus your review point. Each must be checkable with a number or a fact, not a feeling.
  3. Write one thing that is not a reason to sell this holding.
Show a model answer (Costco, from Module 5)
  1. Thesis: members keep renewing and paying fees, which fund low prices that bring more members.
  2. Thesis breaks: the US and Canada renewal rate (92.3% in the FY2026 10-K) falls below 90% two years running. Price past value: price more than 50% above my DCF value. Better use: a new idea I rate higher at similar risk, compared in writing. Too big: above my per-position cap; trim back to it. Review point: the fall I sized with (say 20%); re-read the thesis there.
  3. Not a reason: "it's up 40% this year" or "it fell 15% after earnings".

Next lesson: Measuring your performance honestly, keeping an honest score against a benchmark chosen in advance.