Lesson 7 of 8

When to sell

Step 3 of 6

Worked example

A sell card for an $8,000 Nvidia position, written the day it was bought (21 Oct 2026, at $221.97), in a $100,000 portfolio with lesson 05's 8% cap and lesson 03's 1% risk limit.

Thesis (one line): Nvidia's data-centre business keeps growing because big cloud companies keep buying its AI chips, and its software keeps customers from switching.

Reason Written rule What I do
Thesis breaks Data Center revenue falls year-on-year for two quarters running, or a top customer says it is moving to its own chips Re-read the thesis; sell if it no longer holds
Price far past value Price more than 50% above my DCF value Re-do the valuation; trim if it still holds
Better use A new idea I rate higher at similar risk Compare both in writing first
Too big Position above 8% ($8,000) Trim back to 8%
Review point 12.5% below my buy price ($194.22): the fall I sized with ($1,000 ÷ 12.5% = $8,000) Re-read the thesis (row 1); sell only if it no longer holds

Data: the Data Center line in each 10-Q's revenue-by-market table (Module 5), an end-market breakdown, not a reporting segment.

Now test the card. Nvidia closed at $145.98 on 19 Nov 2026 (Yahoo, closing prices, price-only). It fell 9.3% on 5 Nov alone.

Change = 145.98 ÷ 221.97 − 1 = −34.2%

A fall of a third in a month feels like an order to sell. Check the card:

  • Is a price fall on the card? Only as the review point. By the 5 Nov close ($181.60) the price was below $194.22, so: re-read the thesis. That is all the fall does.
  • Thesis: does the latest quarterly report's Data Center revenue break the thesis line? If yes, row 1 applies.
  • Too big? An $8,000 position is now $8,000 × 145.98 ÷ 221.97 = $5,261, about 5.4% of a portfolio now worth $97,261 (if nothing else moved). Well under the cap.
  • Price vs value: after a 34% fall, row 2 is further away.

The loss so far is $2,739 (2.7% of the portfolio), well past the $1,000 planned: unlike a stop order, a review point doesn't end the loss; the cap kept it small. Decide by the card and note the row you used.